24. It's getting cancelled and good thing too because it's been awful for the past three seasons! Last year's was so painful that I planned on not even following this season... Then I ended up having nothing to do on Monday nights at nine and so here I am, watching recycled scripts and foolish plot lines. Wondering how I ever got to like this show so much and yet still be thrilled with it's cancellation, I decided to watch season 2 on DVD to see if it really was great or if it was all just new and interesting with that real-time thing. I needed to know if I should have been laughing at it all along.
I just finished season 2 and here are my findings.
The earlier seasons of 24 are without a doubt quantifiably better than the more recent ones! I had seen season 2 (years ago) and vaguely remembered it (recalling major plot twists approximately 30 seconds before they happened) but even with that it was still thrilling. Here's a few of the major reasons why:
1. 24. It's a ridiculous idea that the characters are up and in a constant state of adrenaline for 24 solid hours. The characters of season 2 recognized this and acted like it was quite out of the ordinary to be up at 3 AM chasing down suspects. In season 8, it's like the characters know they're characters in a real-time 24-hour TV show. Lawyers pop up in ten minutes when hailed in the wee hours of the morning and parole officers drive from Arkansas like it's no big deal. The out-of-the-ordinary idea that people would go for that long is acted out like it's simply ordinary.
2. Character development. Season 1 and 2 we have someone to hate. Passionately. Sherry Palmer. What a tool! And also some CTU directors/Division dudes. We worry constantly about Kim and her crippling ineptitude and amazing ability to attract bad situations and creepy guys. But in the later seasons we laugh at the bad guys for being so goofy and we aren't emotionally attached to anyone to care if they live or die. They all just seem to come and go so quickly or they're just moles.
3. Viewer Omniscience. We know everything in season 8. We know who the mole is (hated her for a while and probably figured it out before it was revealed), we are shown everything and nothing is left up to speculation. So much more was in the dark in season 2! We were as scared and worried as the characters themselves, not knowing what was going to happen or where to get the vital information. They give too much away nowadays.
4. Plot twists. Ok, so they were still inventing the good twists back then. I think it was season six that reused
Article 25 of the Constitution to depose a President, but when season 2 was live, most of us had never heard of that Article.
5. The main threat. In season 1 all that was in jeopardy was the lives of one federal agent's wife and daughter and a senator. Ok, so the senator was going to be elected to be the best Prez the US has seen since Abe Lincoln, but still. At stake 4 people. The ante is massively upped with a nuclear bomb threatening 10 million. Maybe the writers went too big to quick and it got hard to top. But when you haven't seen 6 six seasons of nukes going off in Southern California, it's pretty enthralling the first time around.
6. My favorite reason why: there's subliminal excitement mixed in. At commercials and at the end of the show there's that clock with the famous "beep-thud". It usually coincides with everyone in the room clenching their teeth and shouting, "AHH! I can't believe that just happened!!!" And in the earlier seasons (I think I first noticed it in 4 and re-confirmed it while watching the DVD of 2) they mix into the background sound/music that little beep. Somewhere deep inside our heads it gets us juiced for something suspenseful when they really use it when people are just talking calmly. Listen for it, you'll hear it. And it gets your blood pumping because you're so used to the excitement associated with the sound. It's gone in the later seasons. :-(
Admittedly those 4 and 6 points of mine are good traits simply from being chronologically first, but my point stands. 24 is getting cancelled because they gave up.